As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

The Best Shingle Remover

Shingle Remover Review

Our Top Pick is the Bully Tools 91110 10-Gauge ProShingle with Fiberglass D-Grip Handle and Notched Teeth

The Bully Tools 10-Gauge is our top pick for a shingle remover because it’s designed to get rid of the shingles quickly and easily, without a whole lot of added effort from you. It’s made with 10 gauge steel to ensure that it won’t break while you’re prying off shingles, which definitely isn’t the easiest of jobs all the time.

It is made entirely in the United States, which can be a great benefit for a lot of people who are looking to support the country and ensure that they make purchases better aligned with those goals. It’s also commercial grade, which means that if you hired a professional it’s likely they’d have something is of equal or similar quality to start scrapping shingles or that a professional could use this tool in their job.

The handle is made with fiberglass to provide a strong and sturdy but still lightweight material that you’ll be able to use and maneuver as long as you need to while clearing off your roof. By using fiberglass it’s possible for you to carry the unit around as long as necessary because it’s not as heavy as a fully steel unit would be to move.

There is a limited lifetime warranty included on the unit itself so you know that it will continue to work for a long time and it’s guaranteed not to come apart as a result of a manufacturer error or any kind of defect in the workmanship of the product. It’s also designed to work properly every time you use it and to not be damaged through normal wear and tear.

The end of the blade has spikes to make sure that it’s really getting underneath the shingles and prying them up carefully and without damaging the house itself or the rest of your roof. The spikes make it easier to get under each shingle and also make it easier to scrape all the way across your roof in smooth motions because they aren’t so wide set or a flat surface.

With a weight of only about 5.5 lbs. this scraper is still 48″ long, making it the perfect size for most users who want something easy to handle but not so small that they have to crouch or crawl on the roof in order to use it. 4 ft. is enough for most people to get a good grip and keep a good movement going as they continue to clear off the roof itself.

The unit also features a D-grip handle which is designed to make it easier to move and hold onto while maintaining comfort and increasing the strength of the scraper. You can easily hold it with both hands and push as hard as you need to in order to get all the shingles off quickly and the handle also gives you good leverage when you need to push something harder.

Who Should Buy This

If you are looking to replace your roof or just the shingles on your roof you may want to get a product like this one to make the job a lot easier and a lot faster at the same time. It will allow you to get all the shingles off faster so if you’re in a hurry you’ll be better prepared to get things done.

For those who aren’t quite sure about hiring someone to get the shingles off their roof but need to have the work done this can also be an important tool which will make the job easier and make it so you don’t have to worry about hiring someone to take care of things for you.

What Makes a Good Shingle Remover

For those who are looking for a good shingle remover you want something that is lightweight enough that you can easily use it over your entire roof over a long setting without having to worry about running out of steam or ending up with pain or discomfort over the long time. It provides you with a sturdy surface to push with as well as pushing on and also allows ensures that there is no breakage.

When scrapping your roof you want a unit that will provide you with enough leverage that you can easily get under the shingles individually and scrape them up and off the roof through the glue and other adhesives that are used to bind them. Your scraper should be able to do just that and should also have no problem breaking away from the shingles when you need it to.

You need something that is durable no matter what you’re coming up against as you might find some spots on your shingles that are not as well adhered and some that are extremely well adhered. You want to make sure that your unit is going to get through everything that you come across and also that it is going to be useful through more than one season by being sturdy and capable of holding up under strenuous conditions.

Shingle RemoverYou also want to consider different options when it comes to a shingle remover because there are the manual type and more automatic versions that will help remove the tiles and shingles on your roof much easier than what most manual tools are able to do. These electric units are more expensive and they require power while you’re working whereas these units will only require you to have the energy to keep going in order to get the best job possible.

An electric unit has many benefits however, in that it can get the job done quick for the cost you’ll pay, and you will be able to get to the process of putting in your new roof much faster with these tools. They are generally not cost effective for most people however, since most people only need to use them once.

If you are running a contracting business or a roofing business these electric units might be a good investment because they last a long time and get the job done faster but for someone who is only using it for their own home it’s not as beneficial.

Finally, you want something that is large enough that you can use it easily but not so large that you have difficulty handling it while you’re working because that’s going to make it more difficult to get the job done the way you want. You need something that is a moderate height that will be usable by a number of people that are different heights as well for overall versatility.

How We Tested

We started out our testing process by talking with a number of people who have had to go through the process of replacing the shingles on their roof on their own, without a professional company to help them. We then discussed what were the most important features when considering this type of product and how it would be used for those individuals and others that are in need.

Once we had narrowed things down we were able to look at the features that each of these individuals found to be the most important and then we started building a new plan for what we wanted as our top pick of scrapers. We were able to finally narrow down the process and find one that our users seemed to agree had the most features and abilities at the right price.

Specifications of Top Pick

  • 10 gauge steel
  • Fiberglass handle
  • 55 lbs.
  • 5″ x 9″ x 48″
  • D grip handle
  • Notched teeth blade
  • 100% made in the USA
  • Limited lifetime warranty

Who Else Likes It

When we start looking at who likes this scraper we find that it’s actually quite popular with customers. One user said that it was an extremely good tool that they could compare to any of their commercial equipment. He was very pleased with the way that it worked and even had purchased it used and didn’t have a problem getting it to work great. It’s very strong and very inexpensive, working about as well as anything more professional so it’s great for those who want to get things done themselves.

Another user said that this tool is better than anything else they had tried. It pulls out nails with no problem and scraps off shingles or even paper shingle siding. This user found that it was a little bit heavy but definitely has plenty of power to be able to get anything and everything that it comes up against with no problems. It’s designed strong and sturdy and that means it’s going to last a whole lot longer than you might think without concern about breaking the handle, or any other parts. It’s also made in the USA, which they definitely liked as an added bonus.

Yet another user found that it was able to strip off two layers of shingles on their home as well as the nails that were pounded in. It’s a little heavy, but that helps get through all of the shingles as well as the paper and the nails and it does all that in a lot less time than most other tools of similar style. This user was able to get everything done in a short amount of time and the tool does most of the work so they really didn’t have to put in too much effort with the process.

Top Shingle Remover Comparison

Handle Size (Inches)
Weight (Pounds)
Warranty (Years)
1Bully Tools-9111048.00
Limited Lifetime
Limited Lifetime
3Bully Tools-9130057.00
Limited Lifetime
Limited Lifetime
Limited Lifetime
9Better Tools54.00
Limited Lifetime

Care, Use & Maintenance

If you’re looking to use this tool for an extended period of time you want to make sure that you’re doing everything you can to take care of it properly and keep it working for as long as you possibly can. You’ll also want to make sure that you’re using it safely and that you’re not getting injured or hurting the tool itself during the course of your uses.

Safety Tips

  • Store in a safe place to avoid tripping hazard
  • Keep sharp teeth covered when not in use
  • Avoid using near other people to avoid flinging materials
  • Be careful to keep sharp teeth away from others
  • Hold with both hands to avoid losing control
  • Move slowly to avoid jamming

Maintenance Tips

  • Walk slowly with a firm amount of force
  • Push firmly under the bottom layer of shingles
  • Keep blade down at all times to get the best leverage
  • Push through nails to pull out while stripping roof
  • Put blade under the edge of the shingle and push firmly
  • Sharpen blades as necessary to get a better edge
  • Avoid using on hard or solid materials such as blacktop or gravel
  • Watch where debris will be thrown at all times

Wrapping it Up

Overall, the Bully Tools ProShingle is a good tool for just about anyone who’s looking to start scraping their roof and replacing the shingles to improve quality and overall durability. It’s designed to be a great leverage tool and pry bar by sticking deep under the shingles and pulling them up along with the nails and backing paper and all.

This tool is able to push through just about anything because of the notched teeth that catch nails as it goes and because of the lightweight form it’s easy enough to use over an extended period while you’re trying to clean off the entire area. It’s sturdy enough that it lasts a long time and there shouldn’t be any problems with breaking blades or teeth.

This tool is also moderately priced for what it does and is considered completely ready for any contracting job or any do-it-yourselfer that wants to put their own roof on (or take it off) without having to hire someone else to do it. It can do just as good as any professional tool in most construction arsenals and takes care of the job easily at the same time.